Oh. Yes. The down side of language development. My son has, within the last two days, mastered the word “no.” Greeeaaat.
For the moment, actually, it’s kind of cute. He’s been doing the negative-head-shake if you ask him a question and he’s not interested. But now we have the vocal “no” to go with it. So far, it’s not a rude-sounding word. Just a somewhat sweet-sounding answer to a question. Or, much of the time, simply a sound he’s practicing. He can be standing off by himself, checking something out, saying “no, no, no, no.” In his very sweet voice, in response to absolutely nothing.
But it’s coming, oh, it’s coming. Soon, I fear, we will make the leap to the loud, whiny, defiant “NO!” And I’m not sure how that one’s going to go.
My husband was raised in a household where “no” was not something you said to your parents. Oh, you might plead and beg and even whine. But you didn’t say “no!” when mom or dad told you to do something. It simply was not done. I will have to ask my mother-in-law how they managed that one. Oh, I’m sure they had some of the typical toddler “no,” but I need to find out how they managed to nip it in the bud.
I’ll keep you posted…
We just tell the boys they do not say “no” to us. Over and over and over. And once we were using 1-2-3 Magic, we started counting them. Obviously they can say no in context (do you want this? no) but refusing to comply is not an option.
Man I sound horribly mean!
oh, I am VERY interested in this one! Z’s favorite word is NO. half the time she doesn’t even wait for the end of the question. and for LauraC, how did you start the counting? I think we are nearing that intervention as we have started climbing the couch and generally being defiant (well, Z mostly)
Yes, PLEASE share how your MIL managed! This is just down the road for us too and I am afraid, very afraid.