The recent events in Paris are unthinkable. The unlivable circumstances in Syria defy reason. The devastation in Beirut is horrific. There is so much ugliness in the world.
I don’t believe in shielding my daughters completely from what goes on outside our immediate sphere, but I also think that it’s my job to mediate this knowledge and protect children’s right to feel safe.
All we parents are back in the quandary of talking to children about terrorism. There’s no one right way to approach it. I had the radio on for a little while driving, but the children were too absorbed in their books to notice what was being said. If it were a different week, I might have chosen to mention the Paris tragedy to my girls, but they’re already dealing with a challenging time within the extended family.
Tomorrow, my 9-year-olds will be back at school. All I can do is prepare myself for any questions they ask and reassure them that they are safe, that our little suburb is too unimportant to be a target, and that Daddy and his soldier friends are out there keeping us safe.
Much as I hate the apathy of the Western world toward tragedy occurring outside our borders, right now the mother in me is grateful. That very apathy is keeping my daughters from feeling that grief, anger, and fear that the Paris attacks have brought me.
Update – Monday, Nov 16
This morning, one of my girls asked me about the Paris attacks. “Mommy, there were bad guy shooters in Paris?” I told her that there were. Her sister had been entirely unaware and wanted details. I just told her that some bad guys decided that shooting a bunch of people would be a good idea, like on 9/11.
Then my first daughter asked whether it wouldn’t make sense if the news people only broadcast kid-friendly stories during the time that most children were being driven to school. I told her that it was parents’ responsibility to determine what’s appropriate for their children, not journalists’. There are plenty of stories that I choose not to let them hear, but I strike a balance between letting them know that people in the world are generally good, but that there are people who make really bad decisions. Unless we have some awareness of the suffering of others, we wouldn’t be able to fully appreciate what we have.
“That’s good, Mommy,” she told me. “That’s a good balance.”
Once again, my children clarified for me parenting decisions that I was over-thinking. Whatever I may be teaching my children, they teach me so much more.
6
0
1
0
0
0
0
I was just having this conversation with Cat (Juggling Act of Life) this morning via her blog. Having children brings in an entirely new level of grief around such a terrible situation, in knowing that you have to put into words for them what’s going on.
Our girls are not quite 7, and I chose not to say anything to them about the Paris attacks. We’ve had some conversations here and there about other tragedies, but I still have the “luxury” at this point of being selective with what they consume.
MandyE recently posted Rare Snuggles
Your last line is what I feel so often. I think I have discovered me more with my children than I would have ever done it
Thankfully I’m too young to understand everything that is happening in the world right now, but in a couple of years my mummy will have to broach the subject
#TwinklyTuesday
Baby Isabella recently posted In the deep dark woods…
I can’t imagine having to explain to my boys about all the ugliness in the world. I’m not sure I would know where to draw the line between whats good for them to know and what they should never have to find out about. Thank fully I have a couple of years still, but I know i’l have to make the same decision one day. So sad. Well done on handling it so well.
Christine Kenny recently posted World Prematurity Day
That’s actually a great idea your daughter had about putting kid-friendly news on for the school-drive times, she has a great way of thinking outside the box! Luckily my son isn’t old enough for any of this yet, and I haven’t given too much thought to how I’ll approach it when the times comes, but my instinct is to protect him from everything scary and hurtful out there. #TwinklyTuesday
Robyn recently posted WORLD PREMATURITY DAY – 17 NOVEMBER 2015
She’s a clever one, isn’t she? My perspective is that if I protect my children too much, they won’t have the grit to make it when I’m not around to protect them, which will have to happen eventually. Like every other challenging part of parenting, it’s about striking a balance.
Thanks Sadia…have been wondering what approach parents are taking here. Luckily mine really are too small to have picked up on anything, but sadly I am only too aware that ugly aspects of life will rear its ugly head on their radar all too soon. I only hope my kids are as level headed as yours. A lovely reflection of you; well done. #TwinklyTuesday
Anna Brophy recently posted MUMMY MUCKED UP
You are so right! I have this debate with myself over and over, my eldest is also 9 #TwinklyTuesday
Mummy Fever recently posted Learning to ski: what’s the best age?
I was wondering the same thing.. my oldest is 7 and I haven’t mentioned it to him yet. If he comes to me I will tackle it then. So awful to have to tell our kids these truths about life #twinklytuesday
Aisling Ozdemir recently posted love thy neighbour (but don’t covet them)
I’ve been wondering what to say to my boys too. The eldest is 17, but the younger two are 6 and 4. Are they to young to talk to about it? Will they hear about it at school anyway? I want them to believe in a world that is good, but I don’t want to shield them so much that they feel lied to. Like you did, perhaps the best thing to do is to be open yet simple, and let them lead the questions. #twinklytuesday
a touch of domesticity / katie sparrow recently posted after the storm: remembering
That last line brought a tear to my eye. This is a really powerful and important topic and it sounds like you handled it beautifully. My son is only a toddler but I often think about I will approach topics like this in the future. Thanks for sharing.
#twinklytuesday
Laura recently posted The Importance of Thankfulness
Mine are both too young to really pick up on news stories yet but it’s only a matter of time. I have the added complication of autism, as well. Tyger is very sensitive and finds it hard to make sense of what other people do at the best of times. I don’t know how I’ll deal with this sort of thing when he’s older but I’ll probably take his lead.
#TwinklyTuesday
Lady Nym recently posted What If There Was a Cure for Autism?
I hadn’t even thought about the additional challenge special needs would present. My girls’ are “special” in that they are very intelligent, which means that they see through any effort to whitewash or oversimplify explanations. The only autistic children I’m close to are either non-verbal or with very low verbal ability, so I don’t think they could understand what happened.
I think its important to talk to school age children because I wouldn’t want their opinions shaped by somebody else. Some of the ideas the teenager comes home with scare me sometimes
jeremy@thirstydaddy recently posted Origins of Hatred
I’ve had to have completely separate talks with my 10 year old (who understands a lot about the world – and has read extensively about historic events like World Wars, tragedies, and the Holocaust) and my 7 and 6 year olds, who believe that bad guys are mostly made up by animators at Disney. Except the ones PopPop (a police officer) “puts in jail.” It’s a testament to all their good character that, no matter how much they understand or don’t, their first reaction is to say “How can we help?” I’m trying to teach them that the most important thing they can do to help is grow up to be understanding, forgiving, and accepting of people from all backgrounds and cultures – because a world where we don’t fear and hate one another is the only kind of world where there can be peace.
Katey Howes recently posted NEW Winter Picture Books & Activities Perfect for Home or Classroom
You must be so proud of your children’s big hearts. Dealing with the different maturity levels isn’t something I’ve had to tackle, since my twins are very closely matched. I’ll keep your approach in mind if I ever have another (likely through adoption).
I love your approach to this and I really think you are right. Our kids show us the way. I read an article from a health care specialist who said exactly what you did, kids need reassurance as they must feel safe. #twinklytuesday
Catie: An imperfect mum recently posted Family Fun: Sinterklaas arrives in Holland
It must be so hard to talk about with children. Marianna’s too young yet but I know it won’t be that long. It’s so important though – because if it’s not you it could be the likes of the tabloids informing all their opinions on the outside world. x #TwinklyTuesday
Jessica Powell recently posted To Self-Host, or Not To Self-Host
I think I’m guilty of over thinking this kind of thing. My two are only small to be fair, but what works for me is just keeping it really simple #twinklytuesday
Rebecca U recently posted Christmas Eve Plate from Lovingly Crafted
Beautifully written and a problem that we all face. I chose this time to tell my 9 year old about Paris as she had asked lots of questions about the last terrorist attack there. This time it doesn’t seem to have caught her in the same way. It’s such a difficult area but I think she knows that we are quite an open book and there will be times when we will censor things that are not necessary for her to see and hear. Of course, they also talk about it in school and observe the silence so complete censorship is not always an option.
How lovely if your daughter to say you had the right balance.
Nicky #twinklytuesday
I’m a bit lucky that both my kids are still young and have not asked questions yet about the evil things going on around the world. However, in the future I need to make myself be prepared to answer their questions in the most appropriate way. Lovely post! #twinklytuesday
Really interesting post. It is so awful what happened in Paris and all over the world but I am thankful my son is too young to know what is going on. I don’t even know how I would talk about such things as I wouldn’t want to scare him but I know one day I will have to make him aware that not all people in this world of ours are good. Until then I am going to just enjoy the fact that he is oblivious to all the wrong doing and to him the worst thing in the world is the fact I won’t let him eat chocolate before lunch xx #TwinklyTuesday
Well, I have to concur that the withholding of chocolate is a crime. 😉
The Tubblet is 12 and we made a point of speaking to her about it before she started school that week. Partly because we wanted to talk to her about Muslims and refugees to make sure she didn’t pick up any bad ideas at school. There’s a lot of prejudice around at the moment.
Mrs Tubbs recently posted We Weep, but We Do Not Fear
That’s a very interesting point. I’m an immigrant, although not a refugee, and come from a Muslim family, so I was just able to say, “They’re claiming that God told them to act this way, but you know that all the religions people we love follow know better.” (My girls are Christian, but they’ve spent time with my Muslim relatives.)
Your daughters sound like wonderfully balanced girls. Well done you
x MMT #twinklytuesday
mummuddlingthrough recently posted #coolmumclub: Meet the Mums…Mum In Brum
Thought provoking. Mine are too young to understand any of it currently, so I have not yet decided what I would tell them. #twinklytuesday
Silly Mummy recently posted Children’s TV: I Have Some Questions
Sometimes children can be so perceptive, it is how they learn and we should never stop learning from them #TwinklyTuesday
Coombe Mill – Fiona Cambouropoulos recently posted Toddle Away with a Toddlebike2
It sounds like your girls have handled what you have told them really well and I agree with your daughter that you have a good balance. It is horrible to have to explain the ugliness and hate that exists in the world to our children. I am thankful that as yet, my children are too young to be aware of what has been happening in the past week but one day I will have to explain these things to them.
Louise (Little Hearts, Big Love) recently posted Gro Light night light review and giveaway
I have absolutely no idea how I would handle this situation. It saddens me that the world is in such a bad state that it is even an issue! Thanks for hosting #TwinklyTuesday
Debbie
Random Musings recently posted My Journey To Being Self Hosted
I love the idea that children teach us a lot. They do, and we should acknowledge it. I must say, I don’t shield my kids from what goes on the world. I think it’s because I’m a former journalist. These things happen and kids need to be told about them, albeit in an age-appropriate way. I’m amazed at the undersatnding my eldest daughter has about the world and all that goes on in it. Thanks for hosting #twinklytuesday
John Adams recently posted It’s International Men’s Day. No, really, it is…
Terrifying isn’t it? And awful that have to try and find the right words to explain these atrocities to our children. Particularly when we don’t really understand how other humans can be so heartless and evil ourselves. I’m dreading the day I have to talk to my babies about this kind of subject. Thanks so much for being such a fab co-host! #TwinklyTuesday One more week for us Sadia!!!!
Caro | The Twinkle Diaries recently posted 141 weeks | Siblings November