Ask the Moms – High Chairs

Posted on
Categories Ask the Moms, Feeding, Infants, Products, Solid Foods, Toddlers

A reader asked through our Features page whether the HDYDI moms have any recommendations for high chairs.  Well, of course we do! But there’s no single “best” option.  It depends on your space and other needs.  We’ll review the two main types: standard high chairs and the ones that strap onto other chairs, as well as give you some tips on what to look for when making your selection.

Standard High Chairs

Certainly the most commonly-seen and with the most available options, the standalone high chairs are what most of us initially think of when it comes to feeding babies and toddlers their “solid” foods. A quick peek at the Babies R Us website shows over 60 chairs by 14 different brands, ranging in price from $45 to $300!  You can go from vinyl upholstery to sleek Scandinavian styling, full-sized with bells and whistles to compact and minimal. That’s one of the main upsides to the traditional high chair: lots of styles and options to choose from. Many have an extra layer to the tray that snaps off and is dishwasher safe for easy clean-up, and they are often cushy and comfy for the kids.  Many also have height adjustments if you want the kids to be sitting higher or lower for easier reach with the spoonful of pureed sweet potatoes.

The downside is space and portability.  Even with the slimmest of models, two traditional high chairs are going to take up a substantial footprint in your kitchen.  While some fold up more easily and compactly than others, the likelihood of you folding and storing both high chairs 3-5 times a day?  Questionable, at best.  For the same reason, they are not especially portable.  Sure, you can fold them up and throw them in the back of the van, but are you really going to want to do that for every little trip over to grandma’s house?

Booster Seats

The alternative is a wide variety of shapes and styles that are meant to attach to a chair or the table.  For today’s purposes, we’re going to stick with those appropriate for babies and young toddlers.  While there’s arguably wider variation in style than the traditional high chairs, there are overall significantly fewer options.  Some of the models strap onto a dining room or kitchen chair, usually with one strap that goes underneath and one that goes around the back of the chair. They have smaller trays than regular high chairs, and often the tray can be removed when you’re ready for the kids to join you at the table.  Some are hard plastic and some are padded, some recline.  The Fisher-Price brand boosters are a big hit among the HDYDI moms.

The second main category are those that hook onto tables.  Definitely consider the sturdiness of your table in relation to the weight of your child when choosing one of these, and know that they don’t work on all tables (like those with a bit of a “lip” underneath).  Also consider whether food will be placed directly onto your kitchen table, in bowls, or on some kind of placemat.  The likelihood being, we assume, that your kitchen table is not dishwasher-safe.  But two of the HDYDI moms have the Chicco brand hook-on chairs and love how much space they save, even if there are phases (say, the early days of finger foods) when everything manages to get spilled in the cracks.  But hey, that will happen with any of them.

While they don’t work in all circumstances, booster and hook-on chairs are a popular choice in twin families for the very obvious reason that they take up much less space.  They just work with furniture you already have and adapt it to your kids.  How handy!  Many of them are also very easy to clean, and fold up compactly for easy travel.

Features to look for

Once you’ve determined what your space constraints and aesthetic preferences are, there are a few other practical matters to consider.  First and foremost is ease of cleaning.  At my house, we have two standard high chairs that are essentially the same, except one has cloth upholstery and one has some kind of plastic/vinyl.  When we were setting them up, my husband remarked that he wished we had gotten both in the cloth, since the vinyl just didn’t seem an appealing surface to sit on for our delicate children.  Then those delicate children began spilling sweet potatoes and banana everywhere.  And everything they ate got mushed into the seats of their chairs.  They got quickly nasty, and it was then that I learned the cloth chair came with instructions to… wait for it… dry clean only.  You must be joking.  I threw caution to the wind and put it in the wash, and it came out just fine.  But still, that cloth one is an enormous pain in the butt to clean.  Even the vinyl one, though it wipes clean more easily, still has a lot of nooks and crannies where things get a little stuck. Anyways, have messy babies in mind when selecting your chairs.

Then, consider any particular features you think you’ll want.  For instance, some people find that it helps to slightly recline babies as they first get the hang of slurping off of the spoon.  Not all chairs recline, but many standard ones do, as do some of the booster variety.  Also test the way the tray comes on and off, and consider how you’d get a wiggly baby into the seat safely.  Check belts to see if you want a five-point harness or a three-point one (honestly, in my big high chair, I almost never use the restraints, as I find the tray keeps them in just fine).

Something Different

A few other notes on high chair options.  One of the HDYDI moms had a stroke of genius: wooden restaurant high chairs! If you can find a restaurant supply store near you, they can be a cheap and stable option, though not portable.  For other money-saving possibilities, don’t forget your local twin club sale and Craigslist.  IKEA also sells the high chairs that they use in the in-store cafeteria: very inexpensive, and they even stack! For traveling, I have really liked the Eddie Bauer Pop-Up Booster seat.  It folds nice and small, and while it’s maybe not the most stable or practical for everyday use, it’s a great thing to keep in the car or take on trips.

Share this...Share on Facebook0Tweet about this on TwitterShare on Google+0Pin on Pinterest0Share on StumbleUpon0Share on Tumblr0Share on Reddit0Digg thisShare on LinkedIn0Email this to someone

11 thoughts on “Ask the Moms – High Chairs”

  1. I have the IKEA highchairs for my triplets. We’re starting rice cereal this week so I can’t totally vouch for them yet, but they do enjoy sitting in them and banging toys around. You can put the chairs next to each other in a way that the legs sort of lock together nicely. I look forward to using them restaurant-style without trays in a few months, too. Definitely worth $19.99 a piece!

  2. I read somewhere the idea of taking those standard high chairs to the local car wash and hose them down. maybe take the kids, too, and do the same? Wait, I think that got someone arrested once.

  3. I’ve got a whole nother option, a feeding table. It’s a pretty utilitarian table with holes cut out in the middle where plastic seats go in. It’s not portable, but you can’t beat the ease of cleaning.

    Costs a little more than I’d like, and I can’t imagine that my babies will make it to 24 months in the seats, but they and I are happy with it now.

    It’s like their desk, they sit and play in it, and for the last few weeks, eat there too.

    For pictures, see:

    It also comes in triplet and quad.

    Love the restaurant high chair idea!

  4. We had the Fisher Price Space Saver chairs. We thought they would take up less space, but if you are going to use them multiple times a day then you leave them up and they take the same amount of space as a regular chairs and you end up losing the use of the regular chairs.

    If I had it to do over again, I’d go with the Ikea chairs or the restaurant chairs.

  5. We have them all. We have 2 hand me down regular size high chairs that were hand me downs. One is an upscale Peg Perego that is impossible to clean and never smells quite right. The other is Fisher Price and is way more practical. Then we bought portable ones like the Eddie Bauer ones (but different brand) that work great for other people’s houses or hotel rooms (you can even set them up on the floor if necessary). Finally we just bought the FP booster seats you link to. They have been great for our vacation and we’ll transition to them at the grown up table when we return home.

  6. Thank you so much for this post! I have been so conflicted on what to do and I now think I’ll go with the ones that fit on our existing chairs since space is already an issue! Right now I’m also trying to decide whether to get another set of cribs or pack n’ plays for nap time on the first floor. I work on the 3rd floor beside the nursery and the nanny takes care of the twins during the day on the first floor…I thought getting 2 of everything was rough but it’s quickly become 4 of everything! Thank God for Craigslist!!!

  7. i was just laughing at the idea of hosing the kids down. because i have done it…in the backyard, not the car wash.

    we have gone down to the bare minimum here, there is a booster at b’r’us that costs 13 dollars or so. very easy to use, very small and (i think) able to grow with them for awhile. i caution you to strap it to a chair and not try to feed them in it while it is on the floor. owen stood up with it strapped to his butt and walked away. funniest sight ever, but not conducive to eating.

  8. I like the clip on high chairs, my favorite being the Phil&Teds Me Too. A friend of mine swears by the Lipper Wooden High Chair, which is just like those traditional a-frame restaurant high chairs – cheap and practical.

  9. TwinMommy – we have a two story house, but the layout isn’t conducive to having just one of stuff, either. I ended up buying a couple kindermats from one of the mom’s in my local multiples group and put them in the living room for naps. They fold up and thus don’t take up the space that PackNPlays do. In fact, I’m about to list my two PNPs on Craigslist. LOVE that tool!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge